On the latest season of the hit HBO show, Succession, there’s this scene with a weighted conversation between a mother and daughter. Throughout the series it is clear the relationship between these two is strained and distant. One evening at a bachelorette party somewhere in Italy, the mother and daughter find themselves sharing more than a cigarette out in the open air. The mother tells her daughter, “You’re my onion.” The daughter returns the compliment.
Last night, after weeping to Tems’ cover of “No Woman, No Cry,” I came to an understanding: my mother is my onion.
I will be turning 31 soon and have been reflecting on the width of my heart—how often it minimizes, how it shrinks its own worth. I’ve been reflecting on how I have had to be my own mother. I cannot remember many days when “I love you” left my mother’s lips or when a hug was gifted to me. But I can remember my kindergarten graduation. A five-year-old Tonya was less impressed with cutesy dresses and more comfortable in a t-shirt and shorts. My mother was embarrassed. One layer of the onion.
I was the good student. I rarely missed days at school, never asked for homework help, stayed out of trouble. But I remember the night she kicked me out of her house over misplaced candy or chips or whatever silly thing that did not matter. This was the first time she’d ever disowned me and meant it. She didn’t ask me to come back. She said I had the devil living inside of me. We didn’t talk for months after that—not until I reached out to her about attending my college graduation. (Most days I think if I did not send that text she would not have been there.) Another layer of the onion.
But the first memory is the one that cuts deepest. As a young mom, she left me with my grandparents to go live her life in New York. New man. New siblings. The first layer of the onion.
This is not to blame my mother for what she did not have but to understand why things feel the way they do. I am needy; I feel undesired; I hold on too tightly; I push people away. I have loved many men and have seen them walk away—some were even difficult to let go of. Some I let inside just to feel something, anything. I am caught between these two truths: I want love, but I don’t deserve it.
When you slice into an onion, there are often tears that follow.
I struggle with control because I am afraid of what I cannot keep. But in the keeping there is a void, and in the void is my mother’s name.
The last time I saw her was in 2019. We barely talk now, and most of our communication is through text messages from my little sister that read something like, “Mom says hi and she loves you.” It feels like grieving a parent who is still alive, like living with the presence of a ghost.
Melissa, you are my onion. This is not a bad thing. It is a map, a blueprint, a layer I peel back to find that my worth was there the entire time. I will be turning 31 soon, and I am proud of the woman I am becoming.
Who or what is your onion, and how are you peeling back the layers—how are you healing?
Deirdre Price says
Thank you so much, it was food for my soul. I cannot express how this lift a burden from my soul. My mother has done so hurtful things towards me but I humble myself by reflecting on good things she has done to help me become strong, faithful and independent. I realized that I had to let go of all the hurt and walk in unconditional love. I had to peel off each layer of the onion and it made me cry. It was a healing and restoration process but now we have a healthier relationship. I thank God ,he help me to let go all the hurt and pain
Thank you for sharing. .
Jennifer Dukes says
This hit hard and settled in the soft wounded places…. That long to heal…
Connie Cohen says
How I can relate to this, but with my father. Reading this brings tears to my eyes, but life can be like an onion one layer at a time one day at a time. Great read!
Brenda Jubilee says
What a touching story, all children need a mother’s love and nurturing. I admire Tonya for sharing her story and she has found strength in living her life.
Lauretta says
This story was so very heartfelt just like an onion, so many layers.
Yes, it can sting like the juice of an onion. Thank you for your story
Miesha says
Growing up, I had no voice… it was taken from me in a subtle way at the age of 8 years old… I was molested… I released it by telling my mother (who also had no voice-see the cycle?) but nothing was done… healing was not present in any type of way. Today, I still FIGHT to have a voice, let alone be/feel heard. I have made some progress (lots of writing lately) but a lot needs to be done personally. The cycle of being silenced runs deep in my family which is why my mom did not know how to handle the situation… living in a small town people talk… everybody knows everybody… it would have been a MESS… anyhoo. That’s ONE of the layers on my onion.
Tunisia Nelson says
As someone currently doing this work and having been through this process you expressed this experience so well. It such a hard and mind boggling experience to feel at your core you are loved but have to find the instances to support that theory. I too can’t recall the last time my mother has said I love you….I know she gives me birthday gifts, wants to know everything im doing, sometimes likes to see me…and I choose to believe that means something
Jackie Williams says
I had to peel back the layers of my mother to understand how we go to a place that I moved out at 16 to live with my best friend and her family, but i believe around the age of 45 or so I started that process and learning so much about her life that i had not known before. This does not give her a pass for be an alcoholic, but it does help me understand the why a little more. Her alcoholism was awful and came with a lot of trauma for me. Thank you for sharing these words.